Not every week of delay on site costs the same

Home » Knowledge » management » Not every week of delay on site costs the same

Every construction contract puts a price on a late week. Few contractors add those prices up across everything they are building at once, writes Dr Albert Ponsteen.

Ask a contractor what a week of delay costs on their biggest job and the answer comes at once, because the contract says so: a completion date, a rate for delay damages and a payment milestone that waits for handover. Ask what a week costs across the twenty or thirty jobs running at the same time and the answer slows down. Each job’s price is on paper. The total, and the question of which jobs carry the expensive weeks, usually is not.

That gap is widest in firms that run many jobs on the same scarce specialists. Some now keep every site in one list, using portfolio management tools instead of a separate programme for each job. A list in software beats a list in someone’s head. But no tool decides which late week costs $30,000 and which costs next to nothing. The business has to price its weeks first.

The price is in the contract. The total is not.

A late week is not one number. Take two jobs, both hypothetical. A hospital wing carries delay damages of $30,000 a week after the completion date, and a $2.4 million payment tied to practical completion. A residential block has no buyer handover until spring, so a week late costs only extra site overheads, say $6,000. Both need the same mechanical coordinator in the same week. Give that week to the wrong job and it costs five times as much, before counting the payment that moves with it.

Nor does the cost climb in a straight line. While float lasts, a week of slip on the hospital costs no damages at all. When the float is gone, the cost jumps to $30,000 a week and the payment waits. A programme that shows every late job in red cannot tell these weeks apart. Only a price can.

The expensive weeks queue in front of the same few people

In most contractors the scarce resource is not concrete or cranes. It is the site manager who signs off every pour, the planner who rebuilds the programme after each variation, the mechanical coordinator, the commissioning engineer, the one specialist gang the region can find. They are shared across jobs, and when they are overloaded everything behind them waits. Adding a job to their list does not make the list move faster. Spread across five jobs, a coordinator finishes none of them by Friday. Worked in order of what each week costs, the expensive jobs finish on time and the rest still get done.

A subcontractor is not capacity you can flex

Work sent to a subcontractor or fabricator is a commitment: four weeks from drop to delivery. You cannot shorten it by assigning more of their people, because their capacity is not yours to allocate. A plan that treats a subcontractor like an internal crew can look right on paper and still be fiction, because the overload disappears only by assuming people nobody can hire. When the package slips, management chases overtime and recruitment, when the real fix is a commercial conversation with the supplier.

Model the package as a lead time instead: the window it takes, the work it gates, and a named line to point at when it slips. The plan then shows which delays you can trade against and which you can only accept or renegotiate. In many contracting portfolios a meaningful share of the critical path sits outside the company, and it is the least visible part of the plan.

Nothing is urgent, then everything is

Early in a programme the finish looks far away. Distance to the deadline reads as spare capacity, so the calendar gets spent: a better finish in the lobby, a “while we are here” variation, a good foreman lent to a neighboring site. Each choice is reasonable on its own. Nobody adds up what is still to come against the hours of the people who must do it. At fit-out and commissioning the total arrives at once, and every package is urgent in the same fortnight, all waiting for the same few people. The crunch is set in the quiet months, which makes the quiet months the cheap time to act.

Price the week before you sign

Contracts are usually signed before the people are assigned to them. That is the moment to price the week, while the answer can still change the plan. Three steps.

First, list every job that is live or about to be signed, with the hours still needed from the named people, trades and plant. Count subcontract packages as lead times, not as your capacity, and count agency labor only for the weeks it is actually booked.

Second, price the week on each job: delay damages, the payment that moves, site overheads, and what the next job loses. For most jobs the honest answer is modest. For a few it is large, and those few are the plan.

Third, rank the list once by that price and start only as many jobs as the scarce people can carry. If money goes to overtime, an extra crew or a contract planner this year, spend it where the week is expensive. Speeding up work nobody is waiting for changes nothing at handover.

Then ask one question before every new signature: which week of this job will be expensive, and who do I need in it? If the answer is a site manager already named on two other jobs, the price of saying yes includes the delay on those.

For a contractor with a dozen jobs, a whiteboard and an honest hour every week will do. For one with dozens, every start date moves the others, and that is where planning software starts to pay its way.

Every contract already knows that a week is not just a week. The plan should know it too, before the contract is signed.

Dr Albert Ponsteen is CEO of Epicflow, a project portfolio platform used by organizations including Rondal, Russell Mineral Equipment and QinetiQ to plan their projects and people. His PhD research at the Open Universiteit examined resource allocation in multi-project environments.