Across a broad range of environments, encompassing the likes of industrial workplaces, construction sites, offices, educational establishments, and public spaces, the ability to measure noise accurately is important.
In today’s era that sees so many people carrying around a small computer in their pocket, it might seem tempting to rely on a smartphone app to check noise levels at a given site or space. However, while such apps can be quick and convenient to use, it is dedicated decibel readers that typically best suit situations necessitating the greatest possible measurement accuracy, consistency, and reliability.
This article, then, will take a closer look at these two popular means of measuring noise. Along the way, information and advice will be set out for maintenance professionals, health and safety managers, and other users who are seeking to determine the most appropriate method for their needs.
Smartphone Sound Apps: What They Are and How They Work
The sound measurement apps available on many smartphones are software applications designed to use the given device’s built-in microphone to gauge surrounding sound levels. Sure enough, most smartphones incorporate one or multiple MEMS (microelectromechanical systems) microphones.
Popular smartphone sound apps to have been offered in recent years range from Decibel X and the NIOSH Sound Level Meter to various free Android options.
A sound-level app on a smartphone typically works by sampling the audio signal, applying digital processing (often including A-weighting to approximate human hearing), and displaying a reading in decibels (dB). This provides the user with an indication of the loudness of the given environment at the moment the app is in use.
Many smartphone sound-measuring apps offer additional features, such as maximum and minimum readings, average sound levels, measurement histories, and graphical depictions of changes in noise over time.
Dedicated Decibel Meters: What They Are and How They Work
Also often referred to as “sound level meters” or Class 1 or Class 2 instruments under the IEC 61672 standard, dedicated decibel readers are tools specifically designed for the purpose of measuring sound pressure levels.
Dedicated decibel readers are the instruments customarily used in professional settings where there is a need to ensure the most dependable possible noise measurements for monitoring, assessment, and workplace safety.
A vital point of distinction is that while the MEMS microphones in smartphones are typically optimised for voice calls and video, dedicated decibel readers incorporate microphones and electronic components designed with sound measurement expressly in mind.
Unsurprisingly, then, dedicated noise-checking instruments tend to deliver more consistent performance, while also incorporating features that are often absent from or less reliable in general-purpose mobile applications.
Those features may include the likes of A-weighting and C-weighting, Fast and Slow response settings, maximum and minimum readings, data logging, and frequency analysis.
Moreover, professional sound level meters can be specified in the aforementioned accuracy classes of Class 1 and Class 2. Sound level meters in the first class generally offer tighter performance tolerances than those in the second.
A Quick Reference for The Differences Between These Options
Here are the key practical differences between smartphone sound apps and dedicated decibel readers that should guide decision-makers’ efforts to make the most informed possible choice for their intended task:
- Accuracy and certainty. Phone apps commonly show ±3 to 5 dB; dedicated meters can deliver ±1 dB or better when properly calibrated.
- Calibration and standards. Apps rely on software offsets or no particular standards at all. Dedicated readers, meanwhile, are calibrated to IEC 61672.
- Frequency and time response. Phones don’t tend to cope well with low-frequency, impulsive, or very loud sounds. Professional meters are able to handle these correctly, with verified filters and time weightings.
- Legal and regulatory acceptance. Smartphones can ultimately only be depended on to provide indicative readings. When it comes to workplace assessments under legislation such as the Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005 in the UK, as well as formal environmental surveys or any measurement that might be challenged, it will be crucial to use instruments meeting recognised standards.
- Cost and convenience. Smartphone sound apps are often free, and they can typically be accessed straight away when downloaded from the relevant app store. Dedicated decibel readers can cost as little as tens of pounds for basic models, although in the case of Class 1 meters with analysis features, budgeting several hundred pounds or more might be necessary.
Making The Right Choice for Particular Noise Measurement Needs
The proliferation of smartphone noise-checking apps over recent years has certainly helped democratise sound awareness, and they can be useful as screening tools. However, these apps cannot be treated as measuring instruments in the metrological sense.
So, in circumstances that demand high standards of accuracy, repeatability, frequency performance, and/or regulatory compliance, it is dedicated decibel meters that emerge as the clear number-one choice.
Comprehensive ranges of Class 1 and Class 2 sound level meters are available from leading suppliers for those who require a professional, consistent, and dependable means of noise measurement.
